Please answer the case discussion questions.
Dominoâ€™s made its name by pioneering home delivery service of pizza in the United States. The company was founded in 1960 in Ypsilanti, Michigan, by Tom Monaghan and his brother, Jim. Dominoâ€™s Pizza was sold to Bain Capital in 1998 and went public in 2004. On May 12, 1983, Dominoâ€™s opened its first store internationallyâ€”in Winnipeg, Canada. And, in 2012, Dominoâ€™s Pizza removed the word â€œPizzaâ€ from the logo to emphasize its non-pizza products. Its current menu features a variety of Italian American entrÃ©es, side dishes, and desserts.
In recent years, the growth for Dominoâ€™s has been overseas. With the U.S. fast-food market saturated and consumer demand weak, Dominoâ€™s has been looking to international markets for growth opportunities. Today, almost all new store openings are outside the United States. As of 2013, Dominoâ€™s had 10,566 stores with 4,900 in the United States, 750 in the United Kingdom, 650 in India, and the remaining spread out in 70 countries. Its plans call for 4 to 6 percent growth in stores per year for the next few years (some 500 new stores annually, with the majority in foreign markets). Given this expansion and clear international growth strategy, perhaps even more amazing is the 76 straight quarters of same-store sales growth in Dominoâ€™s international stores.
As Dominoâ€™s expands its international businesses, there are some things that the company has kept the same as in the United States, and there are some things that are very different. What is the same is the basic business model of home delivery. This sets it apart from many of its rivals, which changed their basic offering when they entered foreign markets. For example, when Yum! Brands Inc. introduced Pizza Hut into China, it radically altered the format, establishing Pizza Hut Casual Dining, a chain that offers a vast selection of American fareâ€”including ribs, spaghetti, and steakâ€”in a full-service setting. Pizza Hut adopted this format because table service was what Page 551the locals were used to, but Dominoâ€™s isnâ€™t interested. â€œWe go in there with a tried-and-true business model of delivery and carry-out pizza that we deploy around the world,â€ states Richard Allison, Dominoâ€™s executive vice presidentâ€“international. â€œIn emerging markets, weâ€™ve got more tables than you would find in the U.S., but we have no plans to lean toward a casual dining model where the server comes out and takes an order.â€
This general strategy is backed up by the CEO of Dominoâ€™s, J. Patrick Doyle, who said that â€œThe joy of pizza is that bread, sauce, and cheese works fundamentally everywhere, except maybe China, where dairy wasnâ€™t a big part of their diet until lately.â€ He continued, â€œitâ€™s easy to just change toppings market to market . . . in Asia, itâ€™s seafood and fish . . . itâ€™s curry in India . . . but half the toppings are standard offerings around the world.â€ Only eight restaurant chains worldwide have more than 10,000 outlets and Dominoâ€™s is one of them (Dominoâ€™s opened its 10,000th store as a franchise-owned outlet in Istanbul, Turkey, in 2012). â€œLocal knowledge and ownership are critical to our success overseas,â€ Doyle said.
Bottom line, Dominoâ€™s is the overall pizza-sales leader in the global marketplace and has established operations with some 5,700 store units worldwide. At this time, Dominoâ€™s is also making a run for the top pizza spot in the United States, which now is held by Pizza Hut (with Papa Johnâ€™s at #3). This entrepreneurial leadership is best captured by Ronnie Asmar, director of new store development for STA Management in Southfield, Michigan, which owns 33 Dominoâ€™s outlets; he says, â€œWe come from an entrepreneurial family in the hospitality industry, and Dominoâ€™s has been an awesome partner.â€
And, Dominoâ€™s appear to lead the market in other ways as well. Dominoâ€™s appear to have captured, integrated, and found an edge in the social media world we live in now better than its competition. For example, Mitch Speiser, a securities analyst for Buckingham Research, in New York said, â€œDominoâ€™s mobile app for ordering pizza is better than its rivals.â€ Information technology also helps drive sales for Dominoâ€™s vis-Ã -vis local pizza entrepreneurs. At this time, about 58 percent of Dominoâ€™s orders are digital in the United Kingdom and about 40 percent in the United States.
On the other hand, some things vary from country to country. In the United States, pizza is viewed as casual food, frequently mentioned in the same breath as beer and football. In Japan, itâ€™s viewed as more upscale fare. This is reflected in the offering. Japanese pizzas come with toppings that the average American couldnâ€™t fathom. Dominoâ€™s has sold a $50 pizza in Japan featuring foie gras. Other premium toppings include snow crab, Mangalitsa pork with Bordeaux sauce, and beef stew with fresh mozzarella. Japanese consumers value aesthetics and really care about the look of food, so presentation is the key. Patrons expect every slice to have precisely the same amount of toppings, which must be uniformly spaced. Shrimp, for example, are angled with the tails pointing the same way. Dominoâ€™s developed their business in South Korea in much the same manner as Japan.
Now, even with these unique toppings in Japan, pizza consumption is relatively low in Japanâ€”the average Japanese pizza customer only consumes the product four times a year. To boost this, Dominoâ€™s has been working to create more occasions to enjoy it. For example, on Valentineâ€™s Day, its Japanese stores deliver heart-shaped pizzas in pink boxes. Heart-shaped pizzas also appear on Motherâ€™s Day. This culture of superb pizzas with high-quality toppings was actually an initiative that was initially demanded by their U.S customer base; over an 18-month period during 2009 to 2011, Dominoâ€™s remade itself and its pizzasâ€”at the same time, it stayed short of adding more than 10 percent in cost to the pizza ingredients.
But back to Japan! To promote the offering in Japan, rather than spending money on commercials, Dominoâ€™s tried to create news, like topics that people talk about. If the topic is fun and hot, Dominoâ€™s believes that people will talk about it, which ultimately translates into better sales. One promotion in particular received heavy coverage. The chain offered 2.5 million yen (about $31,000) for one hourâ€™s work at a Dominoâ€™s store. In all, about 12,000 people applied for the â€œjob.â€ The lucky winner was a rural housewife who had never eaten pizza. She flew to a small island to deliver pizza to schoolchildren, who were also new to pizza. The event received heavy news coverageâ€”free advertising, in other words! As its international focus is now larger and advertisement funds are being allocated accordingly, Dominoâ€™s is moving much more toward TV commercials in its promotional efforts to complement other promotional efforts. This includes Japan, India, and a variety of countries.
In India, where Dominoâ€™s has some 650 stores and has plans for some 1,000 more, 50 percent of the menu is vegetarian in order to match the preferences of the large Hindu population. For delivery, Dominoâ€™s has a fleet of mopeds, which makes sense in large cities like Mumbai where traffic congestion is awful. Because Indians like things spicy, instead of including Parmesan cheese packets, Dominoâ€™s includes an â€œOregano SpiceMix.â€ In general, the toppings have far more spice than in the United States. Although Indians are used to full service in restaurants, Dominoâ€™s doesnâ€™t use servers or busers in its stores, even though each store typically has a few tables in for those who want to eat on premises. Instead, it is educating customers to clean up after themselves, with in-store trashcans that say â€œUse Meâ€ in big bold letters.
Dominoâ€™s today has focused on branding itself with high-quality ingredients, efficiency but at a speed that fosters quality, and a devotion to maintaining a cultural Page 552fabric that allows for a strong entrepreneurial mindset among employees and franchisees. The company captures the global marketplace effectively, either as a first-mover or as a strong follower. â€œFor Dominoâ€™s the development and eventual channelization of industries is important strategically,â€ said Michael Lawton, chief financial officer (CFO) of Dominoâ€™s. He continued: â€œIt led the company to decide in some foreign markets that the best alternative was to let someone else introduce the pizza category with a sit down concept and then Dominoâ€™s moved in and captured their part of the industry as delivery and carry-out developed.â€ In other cases, Dominoâ€™s led the market entry into foreign countries. These decision choices make for great global strategy. Dominoâ€™s has certainly captured the â€œtasteâ€ of the global marketplace!
Sources: A. Gasparro, â€œDominoâ€™s Sticks to Its Ways Abroad,â€ The Wall Street Journal, April 17, 2012, p. B10; A. C. Beattie, â€œIn Japan, Pizza Is Recast as a Meal for Special Occasions,â€ Advertising Age, April 2, 2012, p. 16; A. Gasparro, â€œDominoâ€™s Sees Bigger Slice Overseas,â€ The Wall Street Journal, February 29, 2012, p.B7; R. Shah, â€œHow Dominoâ€™s Pizza Is Taking a Bite Out of India,â€ Getting More Awesome, www.gettingmoreawesome.com/2012/02/08/how-dominos-…; D. Buss, â€œDominoâ€™s Global Growth Feeds Pizza Chainâ€™s Rising Success,â€ Forbes, March 9, 2013.
Case Discussion Questions
- Do you think it is wise for Dominoâ€™s to stick to its traditional â€œhome deliveryâ€ business model, even when that is not the norm in a country and when its international rivals have changed their format?
- What do you think Dominoâ€™s does from an organizational perspective to make sure that it accommodates local differences in consumer tastes and preferences?
- How does the marketing mix for Dominoâ€™s in Japan differ from that in the United States? How does the marketing mix in India differ?
- What lessons can we draw from the Dominoâ€™s case study that might be useful for other international businesses selling consumer goods?